Facebook
Twitter
YOUTUBE
LINKEDIN
XING
About the contributor
Duff Johnson

A veteran of the electronic document space, Duff Johnson is an independent consultant, Executive Director of the PDF Association and ISO Project co-Leader (and US TAG chair) for ISO 32000 and ISO 14289.
More contributions
Interview with Ulrich Isermeyer, Sr. Business Development Manager, Adobe Systems GmbH, about PDF Days Europe 2018

Ulrich Isermeyer, Sr. Business Development Manager, Adobe Systems GmbH, will be hosting a presentation titled “The power of 3D PDF” at the PDF Days Europe 2018. In this Interview he gives some background information about it.

Six Questions to Duff Johnson, Executive Director at PDF Association

Our Executive Director Duff Johnson gives some personally information about his experience with the “PDF universe” and much more.

Interview with Kevin Willems, Software Engineer at iText Software, about PDF Days Europe 2018

Kevin Willems, Software Engineer at iText Software, will be hosting a presentation titled “Redaction in electronic documents” at the PDF Days Europe 2018. In this interview Kevin gives some background information about it.

Interview with Vel Genov, Senior Product Manager at Datalogics, about the PDF Days Europe 2018

Vel Genov, Senior Product Manager at Datalogics, will be hosting a presentation titled “Common PDF Interoperability Concerns” at the PDF Days Europe 2018. In this interview Vel gives some background information about it.

Interview with Matt Kuznicki, CPO of Datalogics, about the PDF Days Europe 2018

Matt Kuznicki, CPO of Datalogics, will be hosting a presentation titled “PDF 2.0 Updates to Rendering and Color Processing” at the PDF Days Europe 2018. In this interview Matt gives some background information about it.

The Case for PDF/UA


PDF/UA icon.Among the greatest contributions of WCAG 2.0 to the cause of improving electronic content accessibility are 4 Principles and 12 Guidelines. These concepts underlie WCAG 2.0’s Success Criteria; they are timeless statements that will shape the technical discussions about implementing accessibility in electronic content for decades to come.

WCAG 2.0’s Success Criteria (61 in all) are most easily understood and directly applied to HTML/CSS/JavaScript and other technologies that were created for the World Wide Web.

Applying WCAG 2.0’s Success Criteria to non-web technologies offers some challenges, a fact that’s readily apparent when one considers the case of PDF. As Adobe Systems put it in their recent blog post:

“PDF/UA defines the technical specifications to enable PDF documents to meet WCAG 2.0, but WCAG 2.0 has additional requirements which require an author’s attention.”

In a recent series of articles posted on his Logical Structures blog, NetCentric Technologies President and PDF Association Vice Chairman Duff Johnson discusses a seminal question in electronic content accessibility: the correct use of headings. He goes on to use this example to unveil some of the distinctions between WCAG 2.0 and PDF/UA.

In the first article, “Heading Levels: Navigation or Decoration” Johnson exposes the distinctions between the definitions of “heading” in HTML and PDF. After discussing how we collectively arrived at this point, he argues that PDF/UA’s requirement for valid heading structures is appropriate in PDF because many PDF use-cases cause assistive technology users to depend on document structure for navigation.

In his second article in the series, “Defining Heading in HTML and PDF”, Johnson reviews in detail the technical definitions of headings in HTML and PDF in order to understand their role in WCAG 2.0. He goes on to suggest that Success Criterion 1.3.1 should be read as normatively requiring correct heading structures, at least in the use-cases (longer and complex documents) common to PDF.

Johnson’s third article asks, “What follows WCAG 2.0?” He points out that while WCAG 2.0 has so far chalked up important regulatory support actual software implementations are lacking. The conclusion makes the point that technology-specific standards are more attractive to implementers while offering more consistent and interoperable results than is likely following WCAG 2.0 alone.

The closing article of this four-part series is an introduction to PDF/UA in non-technical terms. The piece provides five easy-to-understand reasons why PDF/UA matters in terms that make sense to end users.

Read all four articles on Duff Johnson’s Logical Structures blog.

 


Tags: WCAG 2.0, accessibility, logical structures
Categories: PDF/UA